PickOneFromTwo

Pick One From Two

1
CM Punk’s Pipe Bomb & Summer of Punk
86%
Key Players: CM Punk, John Cena, Vince McMahon
Why It’s Great: Blurred reality and fiction. Punk’s unscripted promo lit the internet on fire and redefined fan engagement.

2
Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels – Montreal Screwjob
77%
Key Players: Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Vince McMahon
Why It’s Great: A real-life betrayal turned into on-screen magic. Sparked the Mr. McMahon heel character and changed the business forever.

3
HBK Betrays Marty Jannetty – The Barbershop
71%
Key Players: Shawn Michaels, Marty Jannetty
Why It’s Great: Short but legendary moment. The barbershop window betrayal launched Shawn Michaels as a top heel and later a main-eventer.

4
The Rise of Daniel Bryan
67%
Key Players: Daniel Bryan, The Authority (Triple H, Stephanie McMahon)
Why It’s Great: A real-life underdog story mirrored in the kayfabe world. Fans forced WWE to change their plans. The "Yes Movement" culminating at WrestleMania XXX is a modern classic.

5
Randy Savage & Miss Elizabeth Reunite
67%
Key Players: "Macho Man" Randy Savage, Miss Elizabeth, Sensational Sherri
Why It’s Great: Not just an angle—this was a love story. After losing his retirement match, Savage is attacked and Elizabeth saves him. Crowd sobbing. Pure magic.

6
Seth Rollins Turns on The Shield
62%
Key Players: Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose
Why It’s Great: A shocking, clean betrayal right after a big win. Cemented Rollins as a top heel and split the most dominant faction of the 2010s.

7
Austin vs. McMahon
60%
Key Players: Stone Cold Steve Austin, Vince McMahon
Why It’s Great: Defined the Attitude Era. Anti-authority Austin vs. evil boss McMahon became a blueprint for countless future angles. Explosive chemistry and unpredictability every week.

8
The Shield’s Rise and Fall
58%
Key Players: Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose
Why It’s Great: Dominated the roster, great matches, and the betrayal by Seth Rollins created major stars and long-term consequences.

9
Chris Jericho vs. Shawn Michaels
57%
Key Players: Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels
Why It’s Great: Intense, psychological storytelling. Jericho's accidental punch to HBK's wife added a shocking layer of realism. Easily one of WWE's most underrated rivalries.

10
Triple H Marries a Drugged Stephanie
53%
Key Players: Triple H, Stephanie McMahon, Vince McMahon
Why It’s Great: Over-the-top Attitude Era drama. Hilarious, creepy, and ultimately led to the McMahon-Helmsley era of total domination.

11
KofiMania
46%
Key Players: Kofi Kingston, Daniel Bryan
Why It’s Great: Unexpected grassroots momentum led to a historic WrestleMania moment, with themes of perseverance and representation.

12
The Undertaker vs. Kane
44%
Key Players: The Undertaker, Kane, Paul Bearer
Why It’s Great: Gothic, mythic storytelling. The long-lost brother angle with a supernatural twist. Their first clash at WrestleMania XIV is still iconic.

13
The Rise and Fall of Nexus
43%
Key Players: Wade Barrett, Daniel Bryan, John Cena
Why It’s Great: The debut was one of the most shocking ever - rookies destroying Cena and tearing up the ring. While it didn’t have the payoff it could’ve, the start was white-hot.

14
Randy Orton vs. Triple H – The McMahon Invasion
38%
Key Players: Randy Orton, Triple H, The McMahon family
Why It’s Great: Orton punting Vince, kissing Stephanie while Triple H is handcuffed—it was like a wrestling soap opera. Intense heat heading into WrestleMania 25.

15
Mankind vs. The Rock – I Quit Match & Beyond
36%
Key Players: Mankind (Mick Foley), The Rock
Why It’s Great: Brutality, charisma, and emotion. The “I Quit” match at Royal Rumble 1999 is infamous. Added real depth to both characters.

16
The Return of The Rock to Confront John Cena
33%
Key Players: The Rock, John Cena
Why It’s Great: Brought back huge mainstream attention. The long-term build to their “Once in a Lifetime” match had massive fan investment and generational stakes.

17
The Bloodline Saga
32%
Key Players: Roman Reigns, The Usos, Sami Zayn, Solo Sikoa, Paul Heyman
Why It’s Great: A multi-year epic filled with twists, power struggles, betrayal, and family drama. Roman’s Tribal Chief run reinvented his character and elevated everyone involved.

18
The Mega Powers Explode
30%
Key Players: Hulk Hogan, "Macho Man" Randy Savage, Miss Elizabeth
Why It’s Great: A classic slow-burn story of friendship, jealousy, and betrayal, culminating in an epic WrestleMania V showdown. One of the first truly cinematic stories in wrestling.

19
Edge, Matt Hardy, and Lita Love Triangle
18%
Key Players: Edge, Matt Hardy, Lita
Why It’s Great: Real-life drama brought into the ring. One of the most emotionally raw and personal storylines ever done in WWE.

20
The Festival of Friendship
17%
Key Players: Chris Jericho, Kevin Owens
Why It’s Great: Hilarious and heartbreaking. The perfect mix of comedy and betrayal. Jericho’s reaction - “Why is my name on the list?” - was perfect TV.